The discovery of three Bronze Age arm rings at a potential electricity substation site in Carlisle has sparked a debate about the area's historical significance and the potential impact of the National Grid's plans. The find, described as 'spectacular' by archaeologists, has led to calls for the site to be designated as archaeologically significant.
The torcs, made of gold, were found by metal detectorists Alan Daniels and Andy Crammond on May 23rd in the Blackford area north of Carlisle. Daniels, one of the discoverers, likened the find to the 'holy grail' of metal detecting, highlighting its rarity and importance. The torcs, which would have been worn on the arm, were described as 'incredible' by Gary Robertson, the organiser of the metal detecting rally, who expressed surprise at the discovery.
Dr. Jim Morris from the University of Lancashire praised the find, noting that complete Bronze Age torcs are rare. He suggested that the torcs were likely placed in the ground intentionally, possibly as part of a burial or cremation. This discovery has led to speculation about the connections between Cumbria and Ireland during the Viking period, with Morris suggesting that the link may have formed much earlier.
The find has also raised concerns about the National Grid's plans for the site. Campaigners against the substation argue that the area should be designated as archaeologically significant, while National Grid has stated that it will consider historical finds in its appraisal of the site. However, a spokesperson for National Grid emphasised that expert heritage assessments are conducted, and any verified finds would be carefully considered.
The discovery has also sparked local opposition, with David Coulthard, chair of Westlinton Parish Council, stating that the site is 'not fit for a substation' due to its historic significance. The council and Historic England have yet to make a decision on the site's status, with Historic England stating that no requests have been received to assess the area.
This find highlights the ongoing debate about balancing development with the preservation of historical sites. The rare and significant nature of the Bronze Age torcs discovery has brought attention to the potential impact of the National Grid's plans and the need for careful consideration of the area's historical significance.
